Islamorada Eats: Top Restaurants You Can’t-Miss


Known for its laid-back island vibe and delicious seafood, Islamorada has some of the best places to eat in the Florida Keys. From beachfront cafes serving the fresh catch of the day to fine dining with creative menus, this village offers mouthwatering options for every palate and budget. Foodies flock here for key lime pie, island-inspired tacos, epic happy hour deals, and the freshest fish. Whether it’s your first or fiftieth visit, Islamorada’s diverse culinary landscape never disappoints. When you’re ready to make the island your home, Islamorada FL real estate experts Pine River Realty can help you find your tropical paradise. Come hungry and get ready to discover the restaurants and real estate that make this destination special:

Things to do in Islamorada: Seafood straight from the docks

For the freshest catch cooked to perfection, head to Lazy Days. This popular joint serves plates piled high with succulent, just-caught seafood like mahi tacos, hogfish sandwiches, and coconut shrimp. Pull up a stool at the tiki bar for a local beer or rum runner as you take in the marina views. If you’d rather dine with your toes in the sand, Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar offers a beachy setting right on the Atlantic. Their famous rum-glazed ribs, fish dip, and grilled lobster make it a can’t-miss.

Local favorites

You can’t discuss Islamorada cuisine without mentioning Midway Cafe & Coffee Bar. This opens-at-dawn local favorite plates up mouthwatering breakfasts and lunches. Beloved menu items include the Midway Benedict with freshly-made hollandaise, crab cake eggs, and their off-the-hook fish spread sandwich. For a pick-me-up, grab an iced Cuban coffee made with beans roasted right there. If homestyle Florida cooking is what you’re after, Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen will satisfy you. This tried-and-true roadside gem serves family recipes perfected over 40 years, like their famous fried chicken and cornbread.

Cocktails & bites

When vacation calls for a crisp mojito or inventive craft cocktail, Green Turtle Inn Neptune Bar is a go-to. This vintage Keys joint has plenty of character, along with a strong drink menu and shareable bites like conch fritters and mahi reubens. Another great option is Marker 88. Named one of the country’s most scenic restaurants, Marker 88 delivers spectacular waterfront views and unique frozen and on-the-rocks drinks. Pair your blood orange Paloma or mango margarita with tasty tapas.

Buying a home in Islamorada

Islamorada village offers a serene environment with its clear waters, lush palm trees, and vibrant marine life-rich reefs. When buying a home in Islamorada, be prepared for higher prices due to increased demand, but know that your investment will pay off with endless days spent boating, fishing, diving, and soaking up the sun.

Homes for sale in Islamorada

Known as the “Sportfishing Capital of the World,” Islamorada provides a cool atmosphere and proximity to Key West and Miami. Homes for sale in Islamorada range from condominiums to luxury beachfront estates, with prices ranging from $500,000 to over $5 million. The median listing price is $1.2 million, providing upper-middle-class buyers with a chance to own property in this paradise.